Meet New Books

Books Like...

A daring, darkly satirical reimagining of the JonBenet Ramsey case that skewers media and parental ambition. Compulsively readable for fans of literary fiction and true crime, but its relentless gloom, unconventional style, and length won’t be for everyone.

If you liked My Sister, My Love, here are the top 13 books to read next:

Page 1
Showing 1 - 10 of 13 
  1. #1

    Black Water by Joyce Carol Oates
    Save:

    A short, powerful plunge into the dark waters of guilt, memory, and betrayal - uniquely unsettling and beautifully written, but not everyone's cup of tea.

    In "Black Water" by Joyce Carol Oates, the author vividly weaves a tale inspired by the real-life Chappaquiddick incident involving Senator Ted Kennedy. The novella follows the character Kelly Kelleher as she faces her imminent demise in a car accident, drawing parallels to the tragic events of the past. Through a mix of flashbacks, inner monologues, and intense descriptions, Oates captures the suspense and horror of the situation, keeping the reader engaged as the story unfolds in a quick, impactful manner.

    The writing style in "Black Water" is described as breathless, intense, and economical, providing just enough detail to immerse the reader in the harrowing experience of the protagonist. Oates skillfully navigates the inner workings of Kelly's mind as she grapples with her fate, creating a sense of urgency and inevitability that keeps the narrative gripping until the very end. The book offers a unique perspective on a well-known historical event, delving into themes of tragedy, power, and human nature with a haunting and thought-provoking approach.

    Kelly kelleher had tactfully suggested that The Senator turn on the Toyota's headlights, and now as they made their way deeper into the marshland following what appeared to be an abandoned secondary r...
    1992
    160 pages

  2. #2

    Haunted: Tales of the Grotesque by Joyce Carol Oates
    Save:

    Beautifully written and chillingly ambiguous, Haunted is for readers who want their horror to disturb, linger, and provoke as much as it entertains. Prepare for deeply uncomfortable, unforgettable tales.

    Haunted: Tales of the Grotesque by Joyce Carol Oates is a collection of short stories that delve into the horrors and grotesque elements of everyday life. The stories explore themes such as unwanted pregnancies, abusive relationships, haunting occurrences, and psychological terror. Oates' writing style is described as mysterious, thought-provoking, and unsettling, often leaving readers with a sense of confusion and panic as they navigate through the eerie narratives.

    The book offers a variety of stories that range from subtle and ambiguous to disturbing and surreal. Oates' unique take on modern horror stories presents a mix of traditional scary elements and psychological implications, reminiscent of episodes from The Twilight Zone. The tales focus on the complex relationships between characters, particularly women and abusive men, with underlying themes of fear, panic, and the unknown lurking beneath the surface.

    February 1994
    320 pages

  3. #3

    The Doll-Master and Other Tales of Terror by Joyce Carol Oates
    Save:

    A smart, unsettling collection of literary horror stories: eerily quiet, psychologically sharp, and best for readers who prefer their chills subtle and their stories complex.

    'The Doll-Master and Other Tales of Terror' by Joyce Carol Oates is a collection of six haunting and unsettling short stories that delve into the darker aspects of human nature. Each story presents ordinary characters facing extraordinary circumstances, exploring themes of fear, paranoia, and suspense. Oates' writing style is described as dark, twisted, and chilling, with a focus on psychological insight and subtle horror that leaves readers questioning the boundaries between reality and terror.

    May 2016
    304 pages

  4. #4

    The Gravedigger's Daughter by Joyce Carol Oates
    Save:

    A dark, relentless, and beautifully written novel about survival and identity - unforgettable for fans of literary, character-driven stories, but not for readers seeking light or breezy fare.

    The Gravedigger's Daughter by Joyce Carol Oates is a novel that follows the life of Rebecca, a woman who endures tragic events from her childhood, including fleeing Nazi Germany with her family and experiencing abuse. The book delves into Rebecca's struggles to reinvent herself, protect her son, and find her place in the world, all while confronting her past and undergoing a transformation in identity. Oates explores themes of trauma, reinvention, and the complexities of family dynamics in a narrative that spans generations and continents.

    The writing style of The Gravedigger's Daughter is described as detailed, compelling, and at times challenging. Readers mention the excruciating detail in Oates' descriptions, the potent writing that captures the reader's attention, and the deep exploration of human emotions and experiences. The book is praised for its ability to confront social injustices, sensitively depict the healing process of a wounded spirit, and create a vivid portrayal of the protagonist's journey from childhood to late middle age.

    November 1936. By bus the Schwart family arrived in this small town in upstate New York. Out of nowhere they seemed to have come, with bulging suitcases, valises, bags. Their eyes were haggard in thei...
    2007
    607 pages

  5. #5

    A Book of American Martyrs by Joyce Carol Oates
    Save:

    In A Book of American Martyrs by Joyce Carol Oates, the narrative unfolds with a crime - the murder of Dr. Gus Voorhees, an abortion provider, by Luther Dunphy, an Evangelical Christian influenced by anti-abortion groups. The story delves into the aftermath of this event, exploring the lives of the families involved, their struggles, and the impact of the tragedy on their relationships and beliefs. Oates skillfully presents both sides of the abortion debate through well-rounded characters, capturing the complexity and emotional intensity of the divisive issue. The novel weaves together themes of justice, religion, family dynamics, grief, and loss, providing a poignant and thought-provoking exploration of a controversial and timely subject matter.

    The book offers a multi-layered narrative that delves deep into the characters' perspectives, portraying their struggles, beliefs, and relationships with empathy and complexity. Through shifting viewpoints and rich characterizations, Oates masterfully navigates through the complexities of the abortion debate, presenting a nuanced and engaging exploration of the aftermath of a violent act that reverberates through two families and their communities. The writing style is described as beautifully balanced, emotionally intense, and thought-provoking, making A Book of American Martyrs a compelling and poignant read that delves into the human experience amidst tragedy and moral conflicts.

    So swiftly the Lord executed my movements, there was not time in the eyes of the enemy to register fear or alarm. There was no terror but only raw surprise. As I strode into the driveway in the wake o...
    February 2017
    799 pages

  6. #6

    The Corn Maiden and Other Nightmares by Joyce Carol Oates
    Save:

    A literary, chilling dive into the dark corners of human nature - not your typical horror, but perfect for those who crave psychological suspense and aren’t afraid to be a little unsettled.

    'The Corn Maiden and Other Nightmares' by Joyce Carol Oates is a collection of short stories that delve into the darker side of human nature, exploring themes of evil, revenge, jealousy, and psychological disturbances. The stories are described as chilling, eerie, and unsettling, focusing on characters who are either victims or perpetrators of disturbing acts. Oates' writing style is praised for its vivid characters, deft use of point of view, and absorbing plots that build tension and suspense, drawing readers into the narratives with ease.

    The title story, 'The Corn Maiden', stands out as a particularly twisted and creepy tale, following the kidnapping of a young girl orchestrated by an evil child and her accomplices. Other stories in the collection touch on themes such as sibling rivalry, revenge, loneliness, and the corrupt nature of seemingly normal individuals. Oates' unique approach to storytelling, characterized by dark and disturbing narratives, sets the tone for a collection that explores the depths of human depravity and fear.

    I mean her hair! I mean like I saw it in the sun it’s pale silky gold like corn tassels and in the sun sparks might catch. And her eyes that smiled at me sort of nervous and hopeful like she could not...
    November 2011
    375 pages

  7. #7

    The Collector of Hearts by Joyce Carol Oates
    Save:

    A standout collection for fans of sophisticated, truly unsettling literary horror. Oates delivers haunting, memorable stories, but it's definitely not for the faint of heart.

    'The Collector of Hearts' by Joyce Carol Oates is a collection of dark and disturbing short stories that delve into the realms of horror and the macabre. The stories explore themes such as abusive relationships within families, haunting dreams, eerie obsessions, and unsettling encounters with the grotesque. Oates' writing style is described as breathtakingly written, dark, and disturbed, with a relentless precision that cuts into the tender vulnerabilities of the readers' hearts.

    1996
    360 pages

  8. #8

    Jack of Spades by Joyce Carol Oates
    Save:

    'Jack of Spades' by Joyce Carol Oates is a psychological mystery novel that delves into the blurred lines between reality and fiction. The protagonist, Andrew J. Rush, is a successful mystery author who leads a double life writing darker, more violent novels under the pseudonym Jack of Spades. When he is sued for alleged plagiarism by a woman named C.W. Haider, Rush's identities begin to merge, leading to a descent into madness. The narrative explores themes of obsession, identity, and the consequences of blurring the boundaries between creativity and reality. Oates weaves a complex tale that keeps readers questioning the true nature of the characters and the events unfolding.

    May 2015
    227 pages

  9. #9

    Mysteries of Winterthurn - The Gothic Saga by Joyce Carol Oates
    Save:

    A dark, intricate gothic puzzle best suited for patient readers who delight in language, atmosphere, and a few narrative tricks. Not for the faint of heart or those seeking a quick, easy mystery!

    The 'Mysteries of Winterthurn' by Joyce Carol Oates is a twisty trio of mysteries that turns the entire genre on its head, offering a fascinating and intricate plot that keeps the reader guessing. The protagonist, Xavier Kilgarvan, a young detective, is tasked with solving three cases: The Virgin in the Rose Bower, The Devil's Half Acre, and The Blood Stained Gown. The book is described as being in the Gothic tradition, characterized by its dark and macabre elements, intertwined with supernatural occurrences and a hint of romance. The writing style is noted for its archaic language, which adds to the atmospheric setting of Winterthurn in the 1880s, creating a rich and immersive reading experience.

    1984
    516 pages

    (Also, see 72 recommendations for the series The Gothic Saga )

  10. #10

    We Were the Mulvaneys by Joyce Carol Oates
    Save:

    A beautifully written, emotionally charged portrait of a family's unraveling - haunting, slow-burning, and likely to stick with you, but not for anyone looking for a breezy or upbeat read.

    'We Were the Mulvaneys' by Joyce Carol Oates is a poignant and emotionally draining tale that delves into the lives of the Mulvaney family as they navigate through a tragic event that shatters their idyllic existence. The story follows the aftermath of a daughter's rape at a high school party, which leads to the disintegration of the family and the struggles each member faces in coping with the repercussions. Oates intricately weaves together the characters' perspectives, showcasing their flawed but realistic reactions to the traumatic incident, ultimately exploring themes of resilience, family dynamics, and the impact of tragedy on relationships.

    The narrative is composed of detailed descriptions and explores the daily life of the Mulvaney family, capturing the nuances of their interactions and emotions as they navigate through life's highs and lows. Oates skillfully portrays the devastating effects of the event on the family members, highlighting their emotional responses and the challenges they face in trying to come to terms with the tragedy. Despite the heartbreaking storyline, the book also portrays moments of resilience and the indomitable nature of the human spirit as the Mulvaneys strive to find a new normalcy amidst the chaos.

    You may have thought our family was larger, often I’d meet people who believed we Mulvaneys were a virtual clan, but in fact there were only six of us: my dad who was Michael John Mulvaney, Sr., my mo...
    1996
    462 pages

Page 1 of 2Next Page