Meet New Books

Books Like...

A smart, funny, and emotionally nuanced second-chance romance - great for those who enjoy witty banter and character-driven stories, but may not work for everyone due to some angsty baggage. Still, a strong pick for contemporary romance lovers.

If you liked My One and Only, here are the top 85 books to read next:

Page 1
Showing 1 - 10 of 85 
  1. #1

    Just Some Stupid Love Story by Katelyn Doyle
    Save:

    Packed with sharp banter and a messy but moving journey back to love, this book stands out for its honest look at second chances. It's a hit for fans of angst and emotional realism - just maybe keep a tissue handy!

    Just Some Stupid Love Story by Katelyn Doyle follows the romantic journey of Molly Marks and Seth, who were high school sweethearts before Molly abruptly ended their relationship. The story spans multiple years, capturing their lives and experiences, ultimately leading them to reconnect at their 15-year high school reunion. The plot explores themes of self-sabotage, personal growth, and the complexities of love, as Molly grapples with her childhood trauma while Seth remains devoted despite dating other women. The novel combines humor and emotional depth with clever banter, showcasing both characters’ perspectives and their struggles to find lasting happiness together.

    If your tent is festooned with off-season flowers, or thousands of fairy lights, or embossed linen place cards—if it’s bedecked with a dance floor, a wedding band, a dais for the giving of toasts—rest...
    2024
    336 pages

  2. #2
    My One and Only
    Book 3 in the series:Ardent Springs

    My One and Only - Ardent Springs by Terri Osburn
    Save:

    A heartfelt, drama-filled small-town romance with messy, relatable characters - perfect for fans of emotional love stories, but a pass if you’re tired of romance tropes or explicit scenes.

    'My One and Only' in the 'Ardent Springs' series by Terri Osburn revolves around the story of Dr. Haleigh and Cooper, who have a long history together. Haleigh, a doctor with a difficult past, reconnects with Cooper, her best friend's brother, and they both navigate their feelings for each other amidst family drama and personal struggles. is praised for its well-developed characters, emotional depth, and realistic portrayal of relationships, making readers reflect on issues like coping mechanisms and self-esteem.

    “We’ve had three false alarms in the last six hours,” Haleigh said, dropping paper towels onto the mess. “At this rate, I might as well change careers from delivering babies to delivering pizzas. At l...
    May 2016
    288 pages

  3. #3

    Birthright by Nora Roberts
    Save:

    A twisty, entertaining blend of romance and mystery, perfect for fans of Nora Roberts or those wanting a little heat with their whodunit.

    In "Birthright" by Nora Roberts, the story follows Dr. Callie Dunbrook, an archaeologist who is called to a site in rural Woodsboro, Maryland, after human bones are discovered by workers preparing for a new housing development. As Callie delves into the ancient human remains, she also uncovers shocking truths about her own past, including being kidnapped as a baby and her unexpected reunion with her birth mother. The plot weaves together elements of romance, mystery, and suspense as Callie navigates through personal and professional challenges, all set against the backdrop of an archaeological excavation site.

    The book combines intriguing characters, complex relationships, and unexpected twists that keep readers engaged. Nora Roberts skillfully intertwines multiple storylines, including parallel romances, family dynamics, and a murder mystery, creating a compelling narrative that explores themes of love, discovery, and self-realization.

    It was an unpleasant surprise for Billy himself, who’d been squatting in the cage of his machine, sweating and cursing in the vicious July heat. His wife was staunchly opposed to the proposed subdivis...
    March 2003
    520 pages

  4. #4
    Broken Miles
    Book 1 in the series:Miles Family

    Broken Miles - Miles Family by Claire Kingsley
    Save:

    A heartwarming, grown-up second chance romance with endearing family antics and solid emotional payoff - perfect for fans of character-driven love stories and series you can binge.

    'Broken Miles' by Claire Kingsley is a second chance romance novel that delves into the lives of Roland and Zoe, a divorced couple whose paths cross again when Roland returns to his family's winery business. The book beautifully explores the complexities of their past relationship, their struggles, and the rekindling of their feelings amidst family drama and financial troubles. The writing style captures the emotional depth of the characters and the engaging plot keeps readers invested in the story of love, forgiveness, and redemption.

    My oversized white German shepherd, Edgar, blinked at me, then huffed out a breath through his black nose. I’d taken him for a walk earlier, and these days he needed a nap to recover. His hips tended...
    March 2018
    290 pages

  5. #5
    Love in a Small Town
    by: 
    Book 1 in the series:Pine Harbour

    Love in a Small Town - Pine Harbour by Zoe York
    Save:

    A warm, sexy, and emotionally honest second-chance romance set in a cozy Canadian small town - perfect for fans of heartfelt stories with realistic relationship bumps (and triumphs).

    'Love in a Small Town' by Zoe York is a heartwarming second chance romance novel set in a small town where Rafe and Olivia, a divorced couple, find themselves still deeply in love but struggling to make their relationship work. The story explores themes of forgiveness, second chances, and the challenges of balancing personal aspirations with a committed relationship. Through realistic character growth and relatable struggles, the book delves into the complexities of love and the journey towards a happily ever after.

    IT was bad enough that after going through a very public divorce from the man Olivia still loved, she had to serve him breakfast four times a week. That she looked forward to those mornings…well, that...
    2014
    242 pages

  6. #6

    For Lucy by Jewel E. Ann
    Save:

    An exquisitely written, emotionally charged second-chance romance that will wreck you - if you’re ready for all the feels and a lot of angst, For Lucy is unmissable.

    "For Lucy" by Jewel E. Ann is a deeply emotional second chance romance that delves into the tragic love story between Emmett and Tatum. The book beautifully portrays the complexities of their relationship, the burden of grief and loss they carry, and the journey of forgiveness and healing they embark on. Through a mix of present time and flashbacks, the author weaves a heart-wrenching tale that explores themes of unconditional love, sacrifice, and the enduring bond between the characters.

    The only thing truly perfect about our life was the way I stole her. A brilliant move on my part. We joked about it for years. Tatum would blow her tawny and most unruly bangs out of her eyes, smirkin...
    May 2021
    307 pages

  7. #7
    The Birthday List
    Book 1 in the series:Maysen Jar

    The Birthday List - Maysen Jar by Devney Perry
    Save:

    A heartwarming, gentle romance about grief, love, and moving forward with a dash of hope - perfect for fans of emotional, character-driven stories.

    The Birthday List by Devney Perry follows the story of Poppy, a widow who embarks on completing her late husband Jamie's birthday list to find closure and move forward in life. Along the way, she meets Cole, a police officer who had delivered the tragic news of Jamie's death, and their friendship evolves into something more. The book beautifully portrays themes of love, loss, friendship, and second chances, with a focus on personal growth and healing. The writing style is described as heartwarming, charming, delightful, and engaging, with a touch of suspense that keeps readers hooked throughout a 5-year timeline.

    Gone were the cement floors spotted with oil. In their place was a hickory herringbone wood floor. The dingy garage doors had been replaced. Now visitors would pull up to a row of floor-to-ceiling bla...
    April 2018
    402 pages

  8. #8
    Letters to Molly
    Book 2 in the series:Maysen Jar

    Letters to Molly - Maysen Jar by Devney Perry
    Save:

    A beautifully raw, emotional second-chance romance that’s both heartfelt and real - perfect if you want a love story that earnestly explores mistakes, growth, and redemption.

    Letters to Molly by Devney Perry is a second chance romance novel that delves into the complexities of love, communication, and forgiveness. The story follows Molly and Finn, a divorced couple who are brought back together by a series of letters that force them to confront their past mistakes and unresolved feelings. The book is described as a heartfelt and emotional journey that showcases the struggles and growth of the characters as they navigate their way back to each other. The writing style is praised for its realism and ability to evoke a range of emotions from readers, making it a captivating and relatable read.

    Why did they even need to ask that question? Every loan application, PTA volunteer form and church questionnaire wanted to know your marital status. I was going to start checking the single box. What...
    June 2019
    395 pages

  9. #9
    Golden Trail
    Book 3 in the series:The 'Burg

    Golden Trail - The 'Burg by Kristen Ashley
    Save:

    A dramatic, twisty, and emotionally rich second-chance romance that delivers classic Kristen Ashley vibes - just be prepared for a long, winding journey with lots of heart (and a bit of frustration).

    Tanner Layne and Raquel Merrick, once young lovers, reunite after 18 years in "Golden Trail," the third book in The 'Burg series by Kristen Ashley. The story is a second chance romance filled with angst and drama, centered around Layne's perspective. Despite the challenges they face, the couple works through their past and present issues, including a mysterious reason for Rocky's sudden departure years ago. Set in an Indiana suburb, the book explores complex relationships, family dynamics, and a suspenseful crime subplot, all narrated in a down-to-earth writing style that captures the essence of the characters' emotions.

    He hauled her up and rolled her back, his lips taking hers, his tongue shafting into her mouth. He fucking loved the way she let him kiss her, let him take, did nothing but give. It was contradictory...
    July 2011
    664 pages

    (Also, see 100 recommendations for the series The 'Burg )

  10. #10

    You, Again by Lauren Layne
    Save:

    A fizzy, fun, and spicy rom-com full of sharp banter and electric chemistry - even if a few editing missteps sneak in. Perfect for fans craving smart, tropey romance with a modern twist.

    'You, Again' by Lauren Layne follows the story of Mac, a commitment-phobe who stumbles upon Thomas, a man who is the opposite of her usual type. Their interactions are filled with banter and chemistry, leading to a delightful and heartwarming romantic comedy. The writing style is described as witty, loveable, and easy to follow, reminiscent of classic romance movies from the 90s and 00s. portrays the growth of the characters, especially Mac, and their journey towards finding love and overcoming their differences.

    I glance up from my phone at the bartender, and the fact that she already has the wine bottle poised over my glass makes me think I’m not doing a great job of hiding the fact that I’ve just been stood...
    July 2022
    258 pages

Page 1 of 9Next Page