Books Like...
If you liked All I Ever Wanted, here are the top 9 books to read next:
- #1
A fun, fluffy rom-com with a lovable but flawed heroine and a swoon-worthy hero. Not Higgins’ steamiest or most balanced, but it’s a great pick for comfort reads and laugh-out-loud moments.
In Too Good to Be True by Kristan Higgins, Grace Emerson invents a perfect boyfriend to avoid her family's sympathy after a breakup. The story follows her humorous encounters with her new neighbor, Callahan O'Shea, who is the opposite of her imaginary man. The book is a light, fun read with elements of romance and humor, focusing on Grace's journey of self-discovery and love amidst family drama and relationship troubles.
“AND SO WITH THIS ONE ACT, Lincoln changed the course of American history. He was one of the most despised figures in politics in his day, yet he preserved the Union and is considered the greatest pre...2009•406 pages - #2
A heartwarming, funny romance packed with lovable (and eccentric) characters, but not without a few off-key moments. Great for fans of small town rom-coms - just be aware of some out-of-date humor.
'The Best Man' by Kristan Higgins is a contemporary romance novel set in upstate New York's wine country. The story follows Faith, who returns home after being left at the altar by her gay fiancé. As she navigates her family's vineyard and her complicated past, she finds unexpected romance with Levi, the best man who was involved in the wedding drama. The book is praised for its authentic voice, humor, and themes of family and friendship.
FAITHHOLLANDPUTDOWN her binoculars, picked up her clipboard and checked off a box on her list. Lives alone. Clint had said he did, and the background check showed only his name on the rental agreement...February 2013•426 pages - #3
A flirty, fun college sports romance that blends humor, heart, and real issues. If you’re in the mood for a fast-paced, tropey read with lovable leads and great banter, it’s definitely worth the hype!
The Chase by Elle Kennedy is a college romance novel that follows the story of Summer and Fitzy at Briar University. The book explores their unlikely relationship, Summer's struggles with a learning disability, Fitzy's introverted nature, and their journey towards understanding and supporting each other. The writing style is described as easy, breezy, and engaging, with snappy dialogue, humorous moments, and a perfect balance of important issues and light-hearted romance.
“Is this a joke?” I gape at the five girls who are holding me in judgment. They have various hair, skin, and eye colors, and yet I can’t tell them apart because their expressions are identical. There’...2017•380 pages - #4
A beautifully written, steamy and heartfelt romance that transports you to a cozy bookshop in Big Sur - perfect for those who crave poetic prose, high spice, and the magic of opposites attracting.
Bohemian by Kathryn Nolan is a contemporary romance novel that follows the story of Lucia Bell, a supermodel, and Calvin Ellis, a shy bookstore owner in Big Sur. The book explores the unlikely romance between these two characters who come from different worlds but find a deep connection over their shared love for poetry and literature. As they navigate their relationship, the story delves into themes of authenticity, self-discovery, and the transformative power of love. The writing style of the book is described as poetic and evocative, transporting readers to the picturesque setting of a bohemian bookstore in Big Sur through vivid descriptions and heartfelt prose.
“He didn’t succeed—obviously,” I said, and I saw a few smiles, “but the evidence is captured in this grainy, black-and-white photograph that’s framed on a wall in the bookstore. In it, Ginsberg is lau...September 2017•338 pages - #5
Quirky, steamy, and packed with rom-com charm - Fix Her Up is a guilty pleasure best enjoyed if you like your romance bold, funny, and a little bit over the top. If not, you might want to skip the circus!
'Fix Her Up' by Tessa Bailey is a steamy romantic comedy that follows the story of Georgie Castle, a professional clown who is tired of not being taken seriously by her family and her town. When Travis Ford, a washed-up baseball player, returns home after an injury ends his career, Georgie decides to help him get back on track. The two enter into a fake dating agreement to change Travis's public image and convince Georgie's family that she is more than just the baby of the family. As their fake relationship turns into real feelings, they navigate through witty dialogue, steamy scenes, and a whirlwind romance that challenges their perceptions of themselves and each other.
Georgette Castle tucked the stolen key into her pocket, wincing at the creak as she opened the apartment door. Empty beer cans skittered along the floor the farther she pushed, the stale stench of unw...June 2019•397 pages - #6
A heartwarming, hilarious, and low-angst historical romcom with quirky characters and swoony romance - just don’t come for strict period realism. Perfect for feel-good escapism and animal lovers.
'The Wallflower Wager' by Tessa Dare is a historical romance novel that follows the story of Lady Penelope Campion, an animal lover with a heart of gold, and Gabriel Duke, known as the Duke of Ruin. The book is filled with humor, steamy romance, and heartfelt moments as Penny's menagerie of pets causes a stir in her life and Gabriel finds himself falling for her despite his initial reluctance.
Penny sighed. She had no one to blame but herself, really. She’d forgotten to cover the birdcage completely at sundown, and she’d left a candle burning far too late while she finished a delicious nove...August 2019•373 pages
(Also, see 100 recommendations for the series Girl Meets Duke ) - #7
A funny, feel-good slow-burn with big heart, memorable banter, and an unforgettable Scottish hero. Not flawless, but a top pick if you’re after uplifting, spicy romance with body positivity and genuine character growth.
"Melt for You" by J.T. Geissinger is a contemporary romance novel in the 'Slow Burn' series that follows the story of Joellen Bixby, a shy and insecure woman who has a crush on her married boss, Michael Maddox. When Cameron McGregor, a charming athlete, becomes Joellen's neighbor, he offers to help her win over her crush. However, as they spend time together, Cameron starts falling for Joellen, complicating their relationship dynamics. explores themes of self-confidence, body image, and self-discovery, with a writing style that combines humor, emotion, and a slow-burn romance.
I’m fat. As much as I hate to admit it, the point was driven home with brutal clarity by Granny Gums when she saw me at Thanksgiving and said with a cackle, “Looks like somebody already ate the turkey...May 2018•340 pages - #8
A beloved emotional romance with an unforgettable gentle hero and a focus on healing, but some tropes, writing choices, and plot points may not work for everyone. Worth a try if you're in the mood for heartfelt and steamy with a side of angst!
Archer's Voice by Mia Sheridan is a heartwarming story about Archer Hale, a nonverbal outcast who finds solace in the presence of Bree Prescott as they both heal from their past traumas and build a deep connection. The book explores themes of love, acceptance, and healing in a small town setting, where secrets and betrayals add to the emotional depth of the story. The writing style is described as beautiful, emotional, and swoon-worthy, capturing the journey of Archer and Bree as they navigate their pasts to find a brighter future together.
Grab my hand! I got you,” I said real soft, the helicopter lifting off the ground as Duke grabbed Snake Eyes’s hand. I was trying to play as quiet as I could—my mama was banged up again and I didn’t w...2014•392 pages - #9
A charming, original slow-burn rom-com that’s both uplifting and impactful - perfect if you like your romance tender, funny, and full of heart (but not super steamy).
'The Flatshare' by Beth O'Leary follows the story of Tiffy and Leon, who share a flat without ever meeting in person, communicating only through post-it notes left for each other. The book explores their unique living arrangement, their individual struggles, and the development of their relationship in a quirky and heartwarming way. The writing style is engaging, with alternating first-person narratives that capture the intimacy of their communication and the distinct personalities of the lead characters.
The plot of 'The Flatshare' delves into themes of emotional abuse, relationships, personal growth, and friendship, all while maintaining a light and charming tone. The book is praised for its depth, character development, and the way it handles serious topics like abuse and gaslighting with sensitivity and respect, making it a feel-good and compelling read.
I really can see some positives in this flat. The technicolour mould on the kitchen wall will scrub off, at least in the short term. The filthy mattress can be replaced fairly cheaply. And you could d...May 2019•336 pages










