Meet New Books

Books Like...

Midnight Mass - Priest by Sierra Simone
Midnight Mass
Book 1.5 in the series:Priest
A raw, sexy, and emotional novella that digs deep into Tyler and Poppy's marriage - Midnight Mass is a must for Priest fans craving more, but its heavy themes and angst may not appeal to everyone.

If you liked Midnight Mass, here are the top 44 books to read next:
(We also have 100 recommendations for the series: Priest)

Page 1
Showing 1 - 10 of 44 
  1. #1

    Line of Scrimmage by Marie Force
    Save:

    A heartfelt, rollercoaster ride of a romance about a couple rediscovering love after heartbreak - perfect for those who enjoy deep feels, strong chemistry, and love that’s worth fighting for.

    "Line of Scrimmage" by Marie Force follows the story of Ryan Sanderson, a famous football player, who is determined to win back his wife, Susannah, before their divorce is finalized. Despite Susannah being engaged to another man, Ryan is persistent in showing her his love and dedication. The plot is filled with emotional ups and downs, twists and turns, and a deep exploration of the couple's past struggles, including the loss of their child, that led to their separation. The writing style captivates readers with a focus on the main characters, a steamy romance between a married couple, and realistic insecurities that drive the narrative forward.

    to be Susannah Merrill—excelled at, it was setting an elegant table. Along with sparkling crystal and gold on silver flatware, there were dainty tapered candles perched in sterling candlesticks. A flo...
    September 2008
    363 pages

  2. #2

    Do I Know You? by Emily Wibberley
    Save:

    A heartfelt, playful take on reviving love in an established relationship - engaging, swoony, and perfect for fans of thoughtful romance with a twist.

    'Do I Know You?' by Emily Wibberley is a romantic story of a married couple, Graham and Eliza, who have lost touch and are desperate to find each other again. The couple decides to celebrate their 5th anniversary by pretending to be strangers during a vacation in an attempt to rekindle their relationship. The novel explores the struggles of communication, the ups and downs of marriage, and the journey of rediscovering love and connection between two people who still care deeply for each other.

    The book is told from dual points of view, providing insight into both Graham and Eliza's feelings and perspectives. The story unfolds as the couple navigates through pretending to be strangers, facing challenges, rediscovering their spark, and ultimately striving to save their marriage amidst the adversities they encounter.

    I watch my husband out of the corner of my eye, imploring, wishing he would end the silence filling our car. In the window past him, the ocean glitters, unchanging. The California coastline should ins...
    January 2023
    350 pages

  3. #3
    Taking It All
    by: 
    Book 3 in the series:Surrender

    Taking It All - Surrender by Maya Banks
    Save:

    A scorching, angsty romance packed with drama and heart - perfect for series fans and those craving emotional, high-heat reads, but may test your patience if you prefer smoother love stories.

    Maya Banks' book 'Taking It All' in the series 'Surrender' delves into the troubled marriage of Chessy and Tate. The storyline explores their struggles with isolation and lack of communication, leading to a pivotal moment that threatens their relationship. Readers witness the emotional turmoil, groveling, and reconciliation between the couple, all set against a backdrop of passion, dominance, and love. The writing style captivates with its portrayal of a D/s couple's falling out and hard-won reconciliation, making it a poignant and realistic depiction of marriage in trouble.

    Kylie being there didn’t shock her. Kylie was always punctual. But Joss? Joss was perpetually running late. Chessy and Kylie almost always had to wait on Joss, who’d dash laughingly inside the restaur...
    August 2014
    320 pages

  4. #4

    Lessons in Sin by Pam Godwin
    Save:

    A scorching, emotional, and taboo romance that's perfect for readers who love their forbidden love stories raw, angsty, and unforgettable. Approach with caution if you’re sensitive to dark or explicit themes!

    'Lessons in Sin' by Pam Godwin is a forbidden romance between a student and a teacher, where the teacher is a priest named Father Magnus Falke. The story follows Tinsley Constantine, an heiress sent to an all-girls Catholic boarding school, where she meets Father Magnus. Their relationship is described as unconventional, sinful, and intense, with a slow burn that leads to a bittersweet romance. The book delves into themes of forbidden love, age gap romance, and overcoming past demons, all wrapped in a complex and intriguing plot with elements of mafia underworld.

    I didn’t know anyone here. The air reeked of damp wood and misery. Crucifixes hung on the walls like grisly omens. And the green plaid uniforms? Ew. The color was all wrong for my complexion. I wasn’t...
    June 2021
    448 pages

  5. #5

    Untying the Knot - Billionaire Rom Coms by Meghan Quinn
    Save:

    A steamy, emotionally charged, and refreshingly real take on rebuilding love after marriage woes - prepare for laughs, tears, and some very spicy moments!

    Untying the Knot by Meghan Quinn is a gripping story about Myla and Ryot, a couple facing challenges in their marriage. Myla, who had a rough childhood, struggles with her past trauma and erects barriers around her heart, making it difficult for her to accept Ryot's affections. The book delves into their complex relationship, showcasing moments of passion, raw emotions, and heartbreaking conflicts. The writing style is described as deep, emotional, and raw, with an added level of emotional depth that surprises readers in the best way possible.

    I drum my fingers on the dining room table while staring at the clock on the stove I’ve made several meals on—meals that have felt empty and lifeless. Just sustenance to fill my stomach. Not a meal th...
    November 2022
    483 pages

    (Also, see 100 recommendations for the series Billionaire Rom Coms )

  6. #6

    As Flame to Smoke by Eris Adderly
    Save:

    A wickedly fun, super-steamy novella that turns temptation into art. Perfect for lovers of taboo, paranormal romance who want a quick, provocative escape.

    'As Flame to Smoke' by Eris Adderly is a dark and erotic novella that follows the story of a young Catholic priest named David who is struggling to remain faithful to his vows while being tempted by a seductive female demon named Serah. The book delves into themes of blasphemy and forbidden desires as David and Serah engage in a battle between good and evil, light and dark, with a surprising twist at the end. The writing style is described as phenomenal, gripping, and well-crafted, keeping readers engaged from start to finish.

    January 2018
    99 pages

  7. #7

    Kiss From A Rose by Maya Alden
    Save:

    A raw, emotionally charged journey of heartbreak, growth, and found family. Bring tissues - this one will stick with you long after you finish the last page.

    Kiss From A Rose by Maya Alden is a deeply emotional tale that follows the struggles of Rose, a woman navigating the complexities of her long marriage and the challenges of self-discovery after her children leave home. The plot centers around her tumultuous relationship with Gray, her husband, who often belittles her background and disregards her feelings. As Rose battles depression and the neglect from her family, she finds strength in her friendship with Malou, an unwavering support who helps her reclaim her identity. The narrative captures the raw realities of marriage, family dynamics, and the importance of self-worth.

    Maya Alden's writing style is poignantly relatable, drawing readers in with heartfelt emotions from the start. Her ability to depict Rose's pain and ultimate growth resonates, leaving a lasting impact. The author weaves a narrative filled with powerful moments, showcasing the deep bond between Rose and Malou while exploring the toxic aspects of family life. Fans appreciate Alden's skill in creating authentic characters and profound emotional journeys, making this book a memorable and inspiring read.

    I didn’t make a big fuss over anniversaries or birthdays because I’d learned early on that it would only lead to disappointment. Gray had forgotten a few of my birthdays, and there were times when he’...
    October 2024
    311 pages

  8. #8
    Dungeon Master
    Book 1 in the series:Dungeons and Doms

    Dungeon Master - Dungeons and Doms by Golden Angel
    Save:

    Mature, real, and refreshingly spicy - Dungeon Master is a fantastic, feel-good second chance romance that puts older love front and center. If you want warmth, wit, and heat with a mature edge, this one’s a must-read!

    'Dungeon Master' by Golden Angel is a mature romance novel centered around Gavin and Leah, a divorced couple in their 50s who are navigating the complexities of love, communication, and trust. The story follows Gavin's pursuit to win back Leah, who is hesitant to open her heart again despite still having feelings for him. Set against the backdrop of a BDSM club and a weekly D and D game, the book explores themes of second chances, self-discovery, and the importance of open communication in relationships. The writing style is described as engaging, realistic, and balanced, blending elements of humor, kink, and nerdy references seamlessly into the narrative.

    “I might be too old for this,” Leah muttered, staring at herself in the bathroom mirror. Her blonde didn’t show much grey since it had come in silver, and her hair remained light, but she knew it was...
    May 2021
    216 pages

  9. #9
    Marriage Games
    by: 
    Book 1 in the series:The Games Duet

    Marriage Games - The Games Duet by C.D. Reiss
    Save:

    A scorching, emotionally charged, and captivating read about marriage, secrets, and rediscovery. If you love mature, boundary-pushing romance with high stakes and aren’t afraid of some heartbreak, you’ll want to devour this and jump straight into the sequel.

    In "Marriage Games" by C.D. Reiss, the story follows the marriage of Adam and Diana, which takes a dramatic turn when Diana leaves Adam, leaving him devastated and confused. To prevent a divorce, Adam proposes a unique arrangement where Diana must spend 30 days with him, following his commands as a submissive. As they navigate their complex relationship dynamics, the story delves into themes of dominance and submission, love, betrayal, and self-discovery. The writing style is described as emotionally charged, raw, and gripping, offering a deep exploration of the characters' vulnerabilities and desires.

    Adam, a dominant who struggles to reconcile his feelings for his wife with his BDSM lifestyle, embarks on a journey of self-discovery and emotional turmoil as he tries to win back Diana's love. The plot unfolds with intense and intimate scenes, revealing layers of complexity in Adam and Diana's relationship. The narrative is filled with tension, passion, and unexpected twists, keeping readers engaged as they witness the characters' emotional evolution and the challenges they face in their marriage.

    The morning my life changed was no different than any other. I woke. I showered. The tie I chose wasn’t much different than the other ties in the drawer, and the suit I put on wasn’t much bluer than m...
    2016
    340 pages

  10. #10

    Out of the Woods by Hannah Bonam-Young
    Save:

    A beautifully written, emotionally resonant romance perfect for anyone who loves heartfelt stories about fighting for love and finding yourself, even when you’re already half of a pair. Highly recommended for fans of genuine relationship dynamics and hope-filled, grown-up love stories.

    Out of the Woods by Hannah Bonam Young explores the relationship of Caleb and Sarah, high school sweethearts who married young. The story captures their struggles and growth as they attend a couples counseling retreat to reconnect and rediscover themselves. Through Sarah's perspective, readers witness her journey of self-discovery while she navigates grief and marital challenges, all the while keeping the heartwarming essence of love alive.

    Hannah Bonam Young's writing style is engaging and relatable. She crafts rich characters with complex backgrounds, making their experiences resonate with readers. The narrative balances humor with raw emotions, creating a beautiful portrayal of love's ups and downs. Readers find solace in Sarah's relatable struggles and Caleb's sweet determination to support her. Overall, the book combines themes of healing, growth, and the importance of communication in relationships, making it a compelling read.

    My mother was religious in the same way that leggings are pants. By that I mean whenever times were desperate or for comfort. Never one to shy away from a passive-aggressive “Bless her heart” or an ex...
    January 2025
    352 pages

Page 1 of 5Next Page