Books Like...
If you liked Again the Magic, here are the top 100 books to read next:
(We also have 100 recommendations for the series: Wallflowers)
- #1
A deliciously angsty, deeply emotional historical romance full of pining, passion, and family warmth - if you crave drama and depth in your love stories, don't miss it! Just be ready for a grumpy, tormented hero and a dash of old-school drama.
'Seduce Me at Sunrise' by Lisa Kleypas is the second installment in 'The Hathaways' series. The story revolves around the characters Win and Kev, who have a complex and deep-rooted relationship. The book delves into their passionate romance, filled with tension, obstacles, and a longing reminiscent of a Wuthering Heights-style love story. The writing style captures the emotions and struggles of the characters, particularly focusing on Win's determination and Kev's internal conflicts. The plot intertwines family dynamics, romance, and a touch of mystery, creating a captivating historical romance narrative that keeps readers engaged.
Win had always thought Kev Merripen was beautiful, in the way that an austere landscape or a wintry day could be beautiful. He was a large, striking man, uncompromising in every angle. The exotic bold...September 2008•380 pages
(Also, see 100 recommendations for the series The Hathaways ) - #2
Paradise is a sweeping, nostalgic second-chance romance packed with drama, feels, and a richly layered plot - perfect for those looking to sink into a classic, emotional love story (with a side of boardroom drama).
'Paradise' by Judith McNaught follows the love story between Meredith Bancroft and Matt Farrell, two individuals from different social classes who are drawn to each other despite numerous obstacles. The plot delves into their childhood backgrounds, their struggles in adult life, and the challenges they face in their relationship, including betrayal, family dynamics, and societal expectations. The writing style of the book is described as emotionally engaging, well-paced, and involving elements of love, class mobility, and heartwrenching emotions that keep readers invested in the story.
With her scrapbook opened beside her on her canopied bed, Meredith Bancroft carefully cut out the picture from the Chicago Tribune. The caption read, Children of Chicago socialites, dressed as elves,...1991•740 pages - #3
A unique, steamy cross-class romance with plenty of wit and intrigue - perfect for fans of strong, unconventional leads, though its angst and explicit scenes may not be for everyone.
The Leopard Prince by Elizabeth Hoyt is a historical romance novel set in Georgian England, focusing on the unconventional relationship between Lady Georgina Maitland, a wealthy landowner, and Harry Pye, her hardworking land steward. The book delves into themes of social class differences, mystery, and forbidden love, as the two protagonists navigate their growing attraction amidst suspicion and scandal. The narrative is driven by a mix of tender romance, sizzling passion, and intriguing plot twists, creating a captivating story that keeps readers engaged.
The writing style in The Leopard Prince is praised for its vivid characterizations and engaging dialogue, with a balance of humor, sensuality, and emotional depth. Elizabeth Hoyt weaves together a tale of love, loyalty, and resilience, drawing readers into a world of complex relationships and societal expectations. The book is noted for its well-developed characters, including a strong and relatable hero in Harry Pye, and a charming yet independent heroine in Lady Georgina Maitland, making it a compelling read for fans of historical romance.
After the carriage wreck and a bit before the horses ran away, Lady Georgina Maitland noticed that her land steward was a man. Well, that is to say, naturally she knew Harry Pye was a man. She wasn’t... - #4
A sweeping, emotional, and steamy Victorian romance with lots of drama, darkness, and heartache - perfect for fans of tortured heroes, but may be too heavy for those looking for a light, feel-good love story.
The Highwayman by Kerrigan Byrne is a gripping historical romance novel set in England, featuring the characters Farah Mackenzie and Dorian Blackwell. The story delves into the past of the protagonists, exploring their childhood connection in an orphanage and how it shapes their present lives. As Farah, a widow working at Scotland Yard, encounters the notorious criminal Dorian Blackwell, a complex relationship unfolds, filled with dark secrets, kidnapping, and a marriage of convenience. The writing style of the book is described as intense, touching on psychological themes of trauma, redemption, and the power of love to heal wounds.
Blood ran down Dougan Mackenzie’s forearms as he crouched against the ancient stone wall separating the grounds of Applecross Orphanage from the wild mountains beyond. None of the other children ventu...September 2015•383 pages - #5
Powerfully written, deeply angsty, and atmospheric - The Duke of Shadows is for readers who crave intense emotion, sweeping romance, and don’t shy away from heavy themes. It’s a standout in historical romance, but it isn’t afraid to break your heart a little along the way.
'The Duke of Shadows' by Meredith Duran is a historical romance novel set in India during the time of the Sepoy Mutiny of 1857. The story follows Emmaline Stone and Julian Sinclair, two individuals from different worlds who must work together to survive the uprising. The book explores themes of intense intimacy, passion, grief, and the complexities of relationships during a time of dangerous unrest. The writing style is described as vivid and detailed, with a richly developed atmosphere that immerses the reader into another time and place.
JULIAN FIRST NOTICED HER BECAUSE SHE LOOKED SO bored. Waiting for the Commissioner’s arrival had put him on edge. He stood at the top of the room, half attending to the feverish chatter around him, hi...April 2008•387 pages - #6
A dark, passionate, and high-stakes historical romance perfect for lovers of tortured heroes and epic, against-all-odds love stories. Not for the faint of heart, but unforgettable for those who like their romance with grit and grand emotion.
The Duke with the Dragon Tattoo by Kerrigan Byrne is a historical pirate romance focusing on second chance love. The story follows Lorelai and Ash, two main characters with abusive pasts who embark on a journey to find themselves and each other. The plot delves into violence, realities of the time, and the struggle to earn a happy ending. The writing style is described as gritty, emotional, and packed with action, adventure, and unexpected twists.
He lay facedown, strong arms reached over his head as though he’d been trying to swim through the shallow grass lining the road. Ghastly dark bruises covered what little flesh was visible beneath the...August 2018•372 pages
(Also, see 100 recommendations for the series Victorian Rebels ) - #7
A charming, slightly magical family-centric historical romance with great characters, sizzling chemistry, and plenty of heart - just don’t expect a super serious or entirely conventional regency romance.
'Mine Till Midnight' by Lisa Kleypas is the first book in 'The Hathaways' series, following the story of Amelia Hathaway, who is responsible for taking care of her siblings after a family tragedy. The book introduces readers to a quirky family dynamic, a passionate romance between Amelia and the half-Gypsy Cam Rohan, and touches on themes of family loyalty, independence, and societal expectations. The writing style is described as engaging, with elements of historical accuracy, steamy romance, and a touch of paranormal storyline.
Finding one person in a city of nearly two million was a formidable task. It helped if that person's behavior was predictable and he could usually be found in a tavern or gin shop. Still, it wouldn't...October 2007•391 pages - #8
A beautifully written, heart-wrenchingly angsty second-chance romance with standout characters and a controversial but ultimately rewarding redemption arc - just make sure you’re ready for some serious feels!
'The Day of the Duchess' by Sarah MacLean is a historical romance novel that follows the story of Seraphina, Duchess of Haven, who returns from exile demanding a divorce from her husband, Malcolm, Duke of Haven. The book delves into their tumultuous relationship, filled with regret, anger, guilt, and shattered dreams, as they navigate the past and present to find a way forward. The plot intricately weaves together themes of second chances, love, heartbreak, and redemption, while exploring the complexities of a marriage marred by lies and betrayal.
The writing style in 'The Day of the Duchess' is described as emotionally impactful and beautifully written, with a narrative that interweaves past and present to reveal the depth of the characters' emotions and struggles. The book is praised for its exploration of forgiveness, acceptance, and the possibility of building a future together despite a troubled past, all set against a backdrop of historical accuracy and well-researched details.
August the nineteenth, 1836. The last day of the parliamentary session, filled with pomp and idle. And lingering memory. He spun the wheel with the six embossed upon it. Five. Four. He took a deep bre...June 2017•401 pages - #9
A lush, steamy, and heart-melting Victorian romance with an unforgettable hero, perfect for fans of character-driven love stories - best enjoyed after reading the first in the series for full impact.
"Marrying Winterborne" by Lisa Kleypas is a historical romance novel set in Victorian London. The story revolves around the relationship between Rhys Winterborne, a self-made wealthy businessman with a rough exterior, and Lady Helen Ravenel, an aristocratic woman facing financial difficulties. Despite their different backgrounds, they are drawn to each other, leading to a passionate and tender romance. The writing style is described as vivid and detailed, capturing the Victorian era's clothing, food, and societal norms.
Rhys returned his attention to the letter in front of him. Losing his temper was a luxury he rarely permitted himself, but for the past week he’d been invaded by a sullen gloom that weighted every tho... - #10
A deeply angsty, emotional second-chance romance perfect for fans of historicals with messy, human characters - flawed, passionate, and oh-so-yearning. Some maturation bumps, but plenty of heart.
Readers describe 'Ever Yours, Annabelle' as a historical romance novel set in the Regency era. The story follows the relationship between the main characters, Annabelle and Robert, who have known each other since childhood. The plot revolves around a falling out between the two characters, leading to years of separation before they reconnect as adults. The book is praised for its emotional depth, angsty moments, and the intense longing between the characters. The writing style is described as engaging, with well-developed characters and a storyline that evokes strong emotions from readers.
Mama says I may begin writing to you, provided I also write to John. I do not wish to write my brother, as he is daft and likes to tease me about my nose being too small. Papa says older brothers teas...April 2019•361 pages
(Also, see 100 recommendations for the series Rescued from Ruin )











