Meet New Books
Book Cover

Peter Darling

Save:
Find on Amazon

Who Would Like This Book:

If you've ever wondered what a queer, trans retelling of Peter Pan could look like, this is the book for you. Austin Chant brilliantly imagines Wendy Darling as Peter Pan - a trans boy - returning to Neverland after years of trying to live up to his family’s expectations. The story is perfect for anyone who loves thoughtful character studies, fairy tale retellings, or is seeking sensitive and nuanced trans representation. Fans of enemies-to-lovers romance, emotionally charged journeys of self-discovery, and the magical-but-haunting side of fantasy will find a lot to love here. It's both heart-wrenching and affirming, with standout writing and deep emotional resonance.

Who May Not Like This Book:

Some readers found the book's pacing abrupt at times, and the worldbuilding left them wanting more clarity about Neverland’s rules and side characters. If you’re looking for a tightly plotted adventure rather than an introspective story, or if you’re hoping for richly fleshed-out side characters and communities, you might feel a bit let down. Also, those unfamiliar with Peter Pan might find themselves a bit lost, as the book expects you to know the original story. The romance, while sweet for many, felt a bit forced or too conventional to others, and a few readers struggled with the transition from classic characters to more original interpretations.

Peter Darling is a beautifully written, imaginative, and emotionally honest retelling of Peter Pan with a trans protagonist at its heart. While not perfect in its execution, it offers a fresh, queer perspective on a classic tale - making it a must for fans of retellings, LGBTQ+ stories, or anyone curious to see Neverland in a whole new light.

About:

'Peter Darling' by Austin Chant is a retelling of Peter Pan where Peter and Hook, both fleeing from past traumas, find solace in Neverland. Peter, who is transgender and rejected by his family, and Hook, grieving his past, embark on a journey to seek something real amidst the whimsical distractions of Neverland. The book explores themes of love, acceptance, and self-discovery, with a unique twist on the original Peter Pan story, making it a captivating read for those looking for a heartfelt and poignant tale with elements of romance and fantasy.

Characters:

The characters are richly drawn, especially Peter and Hook, yet some supporting characters lack depth, detracting from the story's overall impact.

Writing/Prose:

The writing style is both lyrical and accessible, with moments of profound emotional depth, though at times it may feel simplified.

Plot/Storyline:

The plot centers around Peter Pan's return to Neverland as a transgender man, exploring themes of identity and acceptance amid conflict with old rivals and new leadership.

Setting:

Neverland is depicted as a transformative and darker version of the original locale, highlighting characters' growth and turmoil.

Pacing:

The pacing of the narrative is inconsistent, starting abruptly but becoming more engaging as the romance and conflict unfold.
"Of course," Peter said easily. He had swum through the ocean of stars, following Tink's directions to the second star on the right. They had burst out into a storm above the island and danced along t...

Notes:

The protagonist, Peter Darling, is a transgender man who initially lived as Wendy Darling.
Peter left Neverland ten years ago to try and fit into the real world but found it unsatisfactory.
The retelling features a romance between Peter and his adversary, Captain Hook.
Neverland in this story has significantly changed, with the Lost Boys now having a new leader named Ernest.
Peter's return to Neverland disrupts an established truce between the Lost Boys and pirates.
The book follows tropes commonly found in fan fiction, like romance and identity exploration.
The relationship between Peter and Hook is built on mutual respect developed through their conflicts.
The writing includes a blend of modern language and period style, which some readers found jarring.
The story touches on themes of acceptance and the complexities of identity regarding masculinity and being transgender.
The narrative explores the darker aspects of Peter's character, such as his impulsivity and selfishness, which have real consequences.
Ernest, the new Lost Boy leader, has a less developed character arc compared to Peter and Hook.
The story features faeries that appear and disappear in ways that serve the plot conveniently, lacking a coherent background.
It contrasts Peter's childish nature with the harsh realities of adulthood as seen through his past experiences.

Sensitive Topics/Content Warnings

Content warnings include transphobia, violence, misgendering, deadnaming, family rejection, and struggling with identity.

Has Romance?

Yes, the romance between Peter and Hook is a central component of the story.

From The Publisher:

Sono passati dieci anni da quando Peter Pan ha lasciato l'Isola Che-non-c' . Ha deciso di crescere lasciandosi dietro il sogno d'essere un ragazzo e ha cercato di rassegnarsi a passare la vita nei panni di Wendy Darling. Ma crescere gli ha solo fatto capire quanto sia impossibile sfuggire alla sua vera identit di uomo. Al suo ritorno, per , Peter trova l'Isola Che-non-c' completamente cambiata: i Ragazzi Smarriti sono cresciuti e i loro giochi di guerra sono diventati reali. E mortali. Ancora pi scioccanti, per , sono l'attrazione che Peter prova per il suo acerrimo nemico, il Capitan Uncino, e la consapevolezza di non sapere pi chi fra loro due sia il vero cattivo.

February 2017
220 pages

Ratings (21)

Incredible (6)
Loved It (9)
Liked It (3)
It Was OK (2)
Hated It (1)

Reader Stats (55):

Read It (23)
Want To Read (20)
Did Not Finish (1)
Not Interested (11)

1 comment(s)

Loved It
1 year

I really enjoyed the queer take on Peter Pan. It's not strictly a retelling -- it's set after the action of the original story. It turns Neverland into an allegory for denial and self-alienation. I was ambivalent for the first half but got totally hooked from there on out.

 
 
Meet New Books is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a way for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to products and services on amazon.com and its subsidiaries.
When you click the Amazon link and make a purchase, we may receive a small commision, at no cost to you.